Daisuke Hotta;
Eugenia Kalnay;
Yoichiro Ota;
Takemasa Miyoshi
Meteorological Research Institute, Japan Meteorological Agency
The 8th EnKF Data Assimilation Workshop
EFSR: Ensemble Forecast Sensitivity to Observation Error Covariance
Poster:
EnKF2018_poster_EFSR_Hotta.pdf
Data assimilation (DA) methods require an estimate of observation error covariance (R) as an external parameter that typically is tuned in a subjective manner. To facilitate objective and systematic tuning of R within the context of Ensemble Kalman Filtering, we introduce a method to estimate how forecast errors would be changed by increasing or decreasing each element of R, without a need for the adjoint of the model and the DA system, by combining the adjoint-based R-sensitivity diagnostics of Daescu (2008) with the technique employed by Kalnay et al. (2012) to derive Ensemble Forecast Sensitivity to Observations (EFSO). The proposed method, termed EFSR, is shown to be able to detect and adaptively correct miss-specified R through a series of toy-model experiments using the Lorenz ’96 model. It is then applied to a quasi-operational global DA system of the National Centers for Environmental Prediction to provide guidance on how to tune the R. A sensitivity experiment in which the prescribed observation error variances for four selected observation types were scaled by 0.9 or 1.1 following the EFSR guidance, however, resulted in forecast improvement that is not statistically significant. This can be explained by the smallness of the perturbation given to the R. An iterative on-line approach to improve on this limitation is proposed. Nevertheless, the sensitivity experiment did show that the EFSO impacts from each observation type were increased by the EFSR-guided tuning of R.
Data assimilation (DA) methods require an estimate of observation error covariance (R) as an external parameter that typically is tuned in a subjective manner. To facilitate objective and systematic tuning of R within the context of Ensemble Kalman Filtering, we introduce a method to estimate how forecast errors would be changed by increasing or decreasing each element of R, without a need for the adjoint of the model and the DA system, by combining the adjoint-based R-sensitivity diagnostics of Daescu (2008) with the technique employed by Kalnay et al. (2012) to derive Ensemble Forecast Sensitivity to Observations (EFSO). The proposed method, termed EFSR, is shown to be able to detect and adaptively correct miss-specified R through a series of toy-model experiments using the Lorenz ’96 model. It is then applied to a quasi-operational global DA system of the National Centers for Environmental Prediction to provide guidance on how to tune the R. A sensitivity experiment in which the prescribed observation error variances for four selected observation types were scaled by 0.9 or 1.1 following the EFSR guidance, however, resulted in forecast improvement that is not statistically significant. This can be explained by the smallness of the perturbation given to the R. An iterative on-line approach to improve on this limitation is proposed. Nevertheless, the sensitivity experiment did show that the EFSO impacts from each observation type were increased by the EFSR-guided tuning of R.
Thanks to McGill's Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences department for hosting this web-site.